Skip to content

Wrong-Way Thinking: How Ireland’s Political Class Responds to Tragedy

    Once again, public attention has turned to road safety in Ireland after five teenage boys were killed when the car in which they were travelling collided with another vehicle while going the wrong way on a motorway.

    The deaths are appalling. But almost as disturbing is what the aftermath has revealed about the institutions supposedly responsible for keeping Irish roads safe.

    At the time of writing, important details have yet to be established publicly. The car was reportedly a stolen BMW, and there have been reports linking its occupants to criminal activity. It also appears that Gardaí were attempting either to intercept the vehicle or were involved in events immediately preceding the crash. Until the investigations are complete, those details should be treated with appropriate caution.

    What requires considerably less caution is the institutional response.

    In the aftermath, it emerged that Gardaí do not have a formal pursuit-driving training system of the kind one might reasonably expect a modern police service to possess.

    Excuse me?

    Police pursue vehicles. Criminals flee from police. This is not some exotic contingency dreamed up by a committee of futurists. Vehicle pursuits are an entirely foreseeable part of policing.

    Yet apparently Ireland managed to construct a policing system in which Gardaí could find themselves pursuing dangerous drivers without having been comprehensively trained for precisely that situation.

    That is not bad luck. It is institutional negligence dressed up as administration.

    And then came the politicians.

    Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan suggested that legislation could be introduced specifically addressing driving the wrong way on a motorway.

    This immediately raises the obvious question: does anybody seriously imagine that a criminal fleeing the Gardaí at high speed, already prepared to steal a car, speed, drive dangerously, ignore traffic signals and endanger other road users, will suddenly stamp on the brakes because somebody in Leinster House has added another offence to the statute book?

    Picture the scene.

    A stolen BMW is travelling at enormous speed. The Gardaí are behind it. The driver approaches a motorway slip road.

    “Hold on lads. We can’t go that way. The minister has just made it illegal.”

    It would be funny if eight young people were not dead.

    This is policymaking as pantomime: confronted with a failure of policing, training, road engineering and risk management, the political reflex is to announce another law.

    Then Junior Minister for Road Safety Seán Canney turned his attention to social media, suggesting that platforms should face pressure or penalties over videos showing dangerous behaviour on the roads.

    Naturally.

    Because when government has no idea how to solve a problem, somewhere in Silicon Valley there is always a convenient villain.

    Social media may encourage stupidity. It may glorify reckless behaviour. There is a perfectly legitimate debate to be had about that. But blaming TikTok, Snapchat, Facebook or X for dangerous driving is not a road-safety strategy.

    It is political displacement.

    Find somebody else to blame. Announce something. Demand a crackdown. Hold a press conference.

    Problem solved.

    Taoiseach Micheál Martin offered another masterpiece of governmental profundity:

    “There can be no tolerance for this reckless behaviour that we have seen on our roads recently. It must stop.”

    “It must stop.”

    One can only imagine Ireland’s criminals hearing this stern instruction and reconsidering their ways.

    This is government by schoolmaster’s reprimand: the assumption that dangerous and criminal behaviour persists because nobody has yet told the offenders firmly enough that they are being very bold.

    The problem is not that reckless drivers have failed to understand Micheál Martin’s disapproval.

    The problem is that reckless people are reckless.

    Criminals fleeing police do not generally conduct a roadside legal audit before deciding which traffic regulations they are prepared to violate.

    And Ireland already has a remarkably relevant precedent.

    On 7 July 2021, three men fleeing Gardaí travelled against traffic on the N7 and were killed following a collision. Garda John Francis Ryan followed the vehicle against the flow of traffic. The Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission investigated the incident, and Ryan was subsequently prosecuted on charges relating to his driving.

    That incident should have triggered an exhaustive review of Garda pursuit policy, training, tactics, command structures and risk assessment.

    Five years later, we are apparently discovering that pursuit training itself is something that ought to be introduced.

    Five years.

    How many committees, commissioners, assistant commissioners, departmental officials, road-safety experts and ministers passed through the system during that time?

    Did nobody ask the breathtakingly obvious question:

    How are Gardaí trained to pursue a vehicle safely?

    Apparently not with sufficient urgency.

    Now, after another catastrophe, pursuit training is suddenly on the agenda.

    This is one of the defining characteristics of Irish public administration. The obvious becomes visible only after somebody dies.

    Then everybody rushes to microphones announcing measures that would have been considerably more impressive had they been introduced before the funeral arrangements.

    Even now, we are told that Garda resources are under pressure because Ireland holds the presidency of the European Union and significant policing resources are required for visiting dignitaries.

    The symbolism could scarcely be better.

    The Irish citizen can apparently take comfort in knowing that while pursuit training waits its turn, Europe’s political grandees will be splendidly protected.

    Meanwhile, the legislative machine will churn out another offence.

    Social-media companies will be lectured.

    Politicians will express outrage.

    RTÉ will assemble panels.

    There will be solemn declarations that “something must be done.”

    And everybody will carefully avoid asking whether the people already paid to anticipate these problems have been doing their jobs.

    There is an even bigger flaw in the Government’s response.

    Wrong-way driving is not solely a criminal phenomenon.

    Tourists have entered Irish roads travelling in the wrong direction for decades, sometimes with fatal consequences. Irish drivers make mistakes too. Confusing junctions, inadequate signage, poor road geometry and badly designed entry points can all contribute to catastrophic errors.

    A tourist who accidentally enters a dual carriageway in the wrong direction is not going to be deterred by a new criminal offence.

    He/she does not know he/she is doing it.

    That is rather the point.

    A Garda pursuit course will not prevent them doing it either.

    Nor will threatening Facebook.

    This is where competent government differs from political theatre.

    Competent government asks:

    Why are drivers entering roads in the wrong direction?

    Which junctions have produced previous incidents?

    Can those junctions be redesigned?

    Can “WRONG WAY” signs be enlarged?

    Can road markings be improved?

    Can directional arrows be repeated?

    Can entry ramps be engineered so that entering them incorrectly becomes physically difficult?

    Can automated warning systems detect wrong-way vehicles?

    Can Garda control rooms rapidly warn motorway traffic?

    What happens elsewhere?

    Which interventions demonstrably reduce deaths?

    Those are engineering, policing and systems questions.

    They are also considerably less exciting than standing in front of a television camera announcing another law.

    Ireland’s road-safety debate has for years had an unhealthy obsession with moralising at motorists. Drivers are lectured, threatened, fined and portrayed as though every collision results from somebody consciously deciding to behave like a lunatic.

    Sometimes people are reckless.

    Sometimes they are drunk.

    Sometimes they are criminals.

    But sometimes human beings simply make mistakes.

    A genuinely sophisticated safety system assumes that humans will make mistakes and designs the environment so that those mistakes do not automatically become death sentences.

    That principle is fundamental to modern safety engineering.

    The Irish political response too often appears to be the opposite:

    The system is perfect. The public are defective.

    So blame the driver.

    Blame social media.

    Pass another law.

    Issue another warning.

    Commission another review.

    And above all, never ask whether the institutions themselves might be incompetent.

    The emerging pursuit-training controversy is particularly damning because vehicle pursuit is not some unforeseeable black-swan event. Gardaí have pursued criminals since criminals discovered motor cars. However, the Gardaí came up with a new policy in the aftermath of a similar event in 2021.

    On 1 July 2023, a teenager driving a stolen car travelled approximately 6 km in the wrong direction on the M8 motorway. He collided with a car resulting in the death of his teenage passenger while causing serious life changing injuries to the driver of the other car. The Gardaí were in pursuit but called it off. A Garda spokesperson was quoted in relation to the incident:

    In almost all circumstances, safety protocols mean pursuing Gardaí are required to call off a chase once a car enters the motorway on the wrong side.

    “They know we can’t chase them and they are taking advantage of that,” said one Garda. “If we do give chase we are the ones facing discipline.”

    That was not idle paranoia. Gardaí had already been given a brutal demonstration of what could happen to an officer who pursued a fleeing vehicle travelling deliberately against the flow of traffic. In an almost identical incident on the N7 in 2021, a Garda followed a car being driven the wrong way along the dual carriageway. The pursuit ended in a fatal collision, and the Garda himself was subsequently prosecuted over his driving. The effect on frontline officers is not difficult to imagine: pursue and you may face prosecution; stand down and watch the fleeing car disappear.

    In May [23], Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said the force was reviewing the procedures for high speed pursuits in light of such concerns after it emerged a Garda is to face trial for dangerous driving for his involvement in a pursuit which ended in the deaths of three members of a burglary gang in south Dublin in 2021.

    Five years later the extraordinary question is not why pursuit training is now being introduced. It is why comprehensive pursuit training was not already considered indispensable.

    The same applies to wrong-way driving. It did not suddenly appear in Ireland in 2026. The danger has been known for decades.

    Government exists precisely because foreseeable problems require organised solutions.

    Any fool can arrive after a tragedy and declare that something “must stop.”

    Government is supposed to work out how.

    Instead, Ireland repeatedly gets government by announcement: legislation instead of analysis, scolding instead of engineering, scapegoats instead of systems thinking, and press releases instead of competence.

    The tragedy on the M7 deserves much more than another round of political theatre.

    It deserves the question Irish governments seem least comfortable answering:

    What did the State know, what could it reasonably have done, and why wasn’t it done?

    Until politicians begin answering that question, declarations about making Ireland’s roads safer should be treated for what they increasingly resemble:

    not policy, but performance.

    And if there is one conclusion to draw from this episode, it is not that Ireland needs politicians who can manufacture fiercer condemnations of reckless behaviour.

    It needs people in government capable of anticipating the freakin obvious.


    PART II — Wrong-way driving did not begin in August 2026

    Perhaps the most damning feature of the political response is the impression that Ireland has suddenly discovered wrong-way driving.

    We haven’t.

    The record shows repeatedly that motorists enter high-speed roads in the wrong direction for radically different reasons.

    Some are criminals.

    Some are reckless young drivers.

    Some are elderly or confused.

    Some suffer medical emergencies.

    Some simply make catastrophic mistakes.

    That distinction matters because legislation aimed at deliberate criminal behaviour cannot possibly prevent all of them.

    December 2016 — M8, Cork

    On 30 December 2016, 84-year-old farmer Tom Joe O’Riordan travelled about three kilometres in the wrong direction on the M8 near Watergrasshill before colliding with a van.

    An inquest heard that he had previously been treated for mild memory loss.

    What additional criminal offence would have prevented that?

    January 2020 — N7, Dublin

    Gerard Prentice, aged 17, fled Gardaí through Tallaght before entering the N7 against traffic.

    The Garda pursuit had already been ordered to stand down.

    Prentice collided head-on with a van and died.

    Making wrong-way driving an additional offence would plainly have made no difference to a driver already fleeing police, speeding, breaking lights and committing numerous other offences.

    July 2021 — N7, Dublin

    Dean Maguire, Karl Freeman and Graham Taylor fled Gardaí along the wrong side of the N7.

    Their BMW collided head-on with a truck and burst into flames.

    All three died.

    A Garda involved in the pursuit was subsequently prosecuted for his own driving during the incident.

    If there was ever an incident that ought to have produced specialist pursuit training and a national review of wrong-way pursuit tactics, surely this was it.

    August 2021 — M6, Galway

    An inquest examined another horrific wrong-way motorway collision in which Jonasz Lach drove at speed along the wrong side of the M6 and collided head-on with a family car.

    All four people involved were killed.

    Again, wrong-way motorway driving was hardly an unknown theoretical risk.

    People were dead.

    June 2024 — M18, Clare

    In June 2024, a motorist was reported travelling north on the southbound carriageway of the M18 in Co Clare.

    He crashed into the central barrier and was taken to hospital in critical condition.

    Reports indicated that a medical emergency was suspected.

    Again ask the obvious question:

    Would creating a new criminal offence have prevented a medical emergency?

    9 August 2026 — M50, Dublin

    Just one week before the fatal M9 collision, a car carrying eight teenage boys travelled the wrong way on the M50 at Junction 12 near Firhouse and collided with an oncoming vehicle.

    Nine people were hospitalised.

    One week.

    Then came the M9.

    16 August 2026 — M9, Kildare

    Five teenage boys died after their BMW travelled against motorway traffic and collided with a family travelling towards Dublin Airport.

    Four innocent occupants of the other vehicle were seriously injured.

    17 August 2026 — M8, Cork

    And incredibly, the following morning there were reports of yet another vehicle travelling in the wrong direction on the M8 between Glanmire and Watergrasshill.

    Drivers were warned to take “extreme care”.

    So much for this being a new phenomenon.

    One problem, several causes

    Put these incidents beside one another and something important becomes obvious.

    Wrong-way driving is not one problem.

    It is a failure mode with several causes.

    A criminal may deliberately drive against traffic to escape Gardaí.

    A thrill-seeker may do it for excitement.

    A confused elderly driver may make a U-turn.

    A foreign visitor accustomed to driving on the right can make a mistake.

    A motorist may suffer a medical episode.

    A drunk or drug-impaired driver may become disorientated.

    A perfectly sober motorist can misread a confusing junction.

    These require different interventions.

    Passing another law might affect deliberate offenders.

    Pursuit training concerns Garda response.

    But neither addresses the confused driver.

    Neither addresses the medical emergency.

    Neither addresses poor junction design.

    Neither addresses inadequate warning signs.

    Neither addresses motorway detection systems.

    This is elementary systems thinking.

    Unfortunately, elementary systems thinking appears to be an optional extra in Irish government.

    The question nobody seems interested in asking

    Instead of endlessly asking how severely motorists can be punished, perhaps somebody should examine how difficult Ireland makes it to enter a motorway in the wrong direction.

    Other countries use combinations of prominent WRONG WAY signage, repeated directional arrows, improved slip-road geometry, cameras, radar detection, illuminated warning systems and rapid alerts to motorway control centres.

    Even the Garda representative interviewed after the M9 tragedy specifically called for consideration of wrong-way detection systems, real-time alerts, cameras, sensors and, where appropriate, physical countermeasures.

    Now we are getting somewhere.

    That is engineering.

    That is risk management.

    That is attempting to prevent the collision rather than deciding which offence to charge somebody with afterwards.

    Modern safety engineering begins with a rather less satisfying assumption than political moralising:

    Human beings will make mistakes.

    The object is therefore to design systems in which foreseeable mistakes are less likely to kill people.

    Ireland’s approach too often seems to begin with the opposite assumption:

    The system is fine. The public are defective.

    So blame motorists.

    Blame reckless teenagers.

    Blame social media.

    Announce another offence.

    Commission another review.

    Express shock.

    Move on.

    Until the next funeral.

    The real scandal

    The scandal here is not that Gardaí refuse to pursue criminals blindly into oncoming motorway traffic.

    They would be insane to do so.

    The scandal is that a problem demonstrated with lethal clarity years ago was apparently allowed to sit there until another catastrophe forced everybody to rediscover it.

    After the N7 deaths in 2021, why was comprehensive pursuit training not introduced?

    Why were motorway pursuit procedures not transformed?

    Why were wrong-way detection systems not examined nationally?

    Why were high-risk junctions not audited?

    Why was the possibility that offenders could deliberately exploit the Garda non-pursuit rule not anticipated?

    Why are these questions being asked in August 2026 rather than July 2021?

    That is the issue.

    Irish governments have developed an extraordinary capacity to confuse activity with competence.

    A minister announcing legislation is activity.

    A Taoiseach condemning behaviour is activity.

    A junior minister blaming social media is activity.

    A Garda review is activity.

    A committee is activity.

    A strategy document is activity.

    None of those things proves that the underlying problem has been understood, still less solved.

    Competence means anticipating foreseeable failure.

    It means learning from previous deaths.

    It means giving frontline Gardaí the training and systems they need before the next pursuit begins.

    It means designing roads for fallible human beings rather than imaginary perfect drivers.

    It means distinguishing criminal recklessness from human error.

    And it means resisting the irresistible political temptation to announce a new law every time reality exposes the inadequacy of the old system.

    Ireland does not suffer from a shortage of laws.

    It suffers from a shortage of institutional memory, accountability and intelligent implementation.

    After each catastrophe the political establishment behaves as though it has awakened that morning in a country it has never governed before.

    Nobody knew.

    Nobody anticipated.

    Something must be done.

    Something will be reviewed.

    Something will be legislated for.

    Somebody else will be blamed.

    And the cameras move on.

    If there is one lesson to take from this tragedy, it is not Micheál Martin’s profound discovery that reckless behaviour “must stop.”

    Any fool knows that.

    The purpose of government is to know how to reduce it, how to prepare for it and how to protect innocent people when it happens anyway.

    That requires foresight.

    It requires competence.

    It requires institutional learning.

    And after five years in which the warning signs were written not merely on reports but in wreckage and bodies on Irish roads, the revelation that Gardaí still had no trained pursuit drivers is a devastating commentary on the people running the State.

    They are very good at arriving after the crash.

    What Ireland desperately needs are people capable of thinking before it.

    EJ

    References

    https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/2023/07/01/teenager-dies-in-two-vehicle-crash-in-cork-after-car-drives-wrong-way-down-m8

    https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-20437173.html

    French tourist forgets which side to drive on, causes car crash

    Cite this article
    Jordan, Eugene. "Wrong-Way Thinking: How Ireland’s Political Class Responds to Tragedy." Institutional Systems Analysis. 2026. Accessed on November 18, 2026 at 08:15. https://eugenejordan.ie/wrong-way-thinking-how-irelands-political-class-responds-to-tragedy/.
    Exit mobile version