Concise analyses of current policy developments. Structured for clarity, neutrality, and practical use.
The Dead Children of Tuam Born to Married Parents
Public discussion of Tuam has been shaped by a quiet but consequential act of reframing. A children’s institution known contemporaneously as St Mary’s Children’s Home, Tuam, or simply “the Home”, has been retroactively reclassified as a “mother and baby home”. This terminological shift is not an innocuous modernisation. It carries a powerful implication: that the…
Methodological Failures in the Reports of theCommission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes
This briefing addresses the analytical shortcomings of the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes. It does not dispute documented hardship, nor does it assess moral responsibility. Its sole concern is whether the Commission’s methods support the causal claims it advances. They do not.
What the Commission of Investigation Got Right
This briefing document identifies areas in which the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes acted appropriately, gathered material of lasting value, or reached conclusions that were methodologically sound within their limits. Acknowledging these strengths is essential to distinguish genuine analytical failure from blanket rejection.
The issue of the “survivors”
Public discussion of Tuam and other institutions is now dominated by accounts that did not originate inside the institutions themselves. A large proportion of those who publicly allege abuse were never resident in any home. Among the stories that circulate, some are plausible and grounded in experience; others are exaggerated, incoherent, or demonstrably false. At…
