Skip to content

Historiography & Method

How interpretation becomes historical “fact.”
These essays explore evidence, inference, and the mechanisms through which narratives harden into accepted knowledge.

History is not only about events. It is about how claims about those events are assembled, tested, and repeated.

This section examines how historical knowledge is produced: what counts as evidence, how interpretation becomes explanation, and how narratives come to feel settled even when the proof beneath them is thinner than assumed.

The essays explore questions of evidence, inference, standards of proof, and the formation of scholarly consensus. Particular attention is given to how interpretations move through citation, repetition, and institutional endorsement until they appear self-evident.

The principle is simple: strong evidence supports firm conclusions. Limited evidence requires limited claims.

The aim is methodological clarity: claims should never exceed the evidence that supports them.

This section is intended as a contribution to that discipline.

  • Irish Children’s Burial Grounds (Cillíní) Reconsidered

    The interpretation of Irish cillíní, traditionally understood as children’s burial grounds, has long been shaped by a dominant narrative that frames them as marginal, secretive, and socially exclusionary spaces. Often associated with unbaptised infants, shame, night burial, and ecclesiastical prohibition, these sites have been treated as material expressions of religious rigidity and social ostracisation. Yet…

    Read Essay

  • Epistemic Capture in the Mother and Baby Homes Commission

    This essay examines that process in relation to the Irish Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes (2015–2021). Rather than revisiting the moral questions surrounding these institutions, the focus here is methodological. The question is how historical conclusions are produced when an inquiry operates within an already powerful narrative environment.

    Read Essay

  • Inference Laundering: How Narratives Manufacture Certainty

    Several media accounts accompanying the publication of the Final Report of the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes described twentieth-century Ireland as possessing a “deeply misogynistic culture.” This characterisation, however, does not originate in the Commission’s own findings or analytical vocabulary. Rather, it derives from political commentary surrounding the report’s publication, most notably…

    Read Essay

Exit mobile version