Skip to content

350 Excess Road Fatalities Since 2020

    Ireland, Sweden — and a Measurable Outcomes Gap

    Between 2020 and 2025, roughly 350 more people died on Irish roads than would have been expected had Ireland matched Sweden’s road fatality rate.

    That is not a dramatic accusation. It is simply a comparison of outcomes.

    Sweden has sustained a road death rate of about 20 per million population in recent years. Ireland’s population over the same period ranged from roughly five to 5.3 million. At Sweden’s level of performance, Ireland would have expected around 100 to 106 road deaths per year.

    Actual figures were consistently higher.

    Add the difference across six years and the gap approaches 350 lives.

    Even if one adjusts Sweden’s benchmark upward to 22–24 per million — a conservative move — the cumulative difference still falls somewhere between 230 and 290 deaths. The direction of travel doesn’t change.

    What changes is whether we are willing to look at it.


    What Explains the Gap?

    Ireland formally supports Vision Zero, the commitment to eliminate road deaths by 2050. The language is there. The strategic documents exist. Awareness campaigns are plentiful.

    But endorsement is not implementation.

    In safety science, two broad approaches are often distinguished.

    The first — commonly called Safety-I — responds to fatalities by identifying what went wrong and seeking correction. More enforcement. Higher fines. Stronger messaging. It makes intuitive sense and sits comfortably with political culture: find the breach, strengthen deterrence.

    The second — often described as Safety-II — starts from a different premise: human error is inevitable. Rather than trying to eliminate mistakes, the system is redesigned so that ordinary mistakes do not become fatal.

    Sweden’s improvements over the last two decades have largely involved changes to infrastructure: median barriers, intersection redesign, traffic-calming geometry, separation of vulnerable road users. The emphasis is structural rather than behavioural.

    Ireland has tended toward the opposite emphasis. Penalty increases in 2022 were followed, in the subsequent two years, by a marked rise in fatalities of roughly 40 percent. Enforcement intensified. Outcomes deteriorated.

    That does not imply indifference or incompetence. It suggests something more familiar in public administration: institutional inertia. Systems default to what feels decisive.

    Sanctions feel decisive. Geometry does not.


    A Governance Question

    The difference between Sweden and Ireland is often presented as cultural or attitudinal. That explanation is too easy.

    The more technical question is whether systems-level safety expertise — human factors engineering, error-tolerant design, impact modelling — is embedded at executive decision-making level. In aviation and rail, it has been for decades. In those fields, a reliance on post-incident blame would be regarded as obsolete.

    Road safety, however, still carries the residue of moral language: compliance, responsibility, deviance.

    One model treats a fatal collision as the predictable output of system design interacting with fallible humans. The other treats it primarily as behavioural failure.

    The measurable gap between Ireland and Sweden reflects which philosophy is doing the real work.


    Irish Road Deaths (Public Roads)

    Widely cited annual totals from the Road Safety Authority (RSA) and An Garda Síochána:

    YearFatalities
    2020146
    2021130
    2022155
    2023184
    2024174 (provisional)
    2025185

    Notes:
    • For 2020–2023, the widely cited annual counts are from RSA sources and secondary reporting of RSA/Garda statistics.
    • For 2025, RSA reported 185 deaths on public roads (others report a slightly different total including all locations).
    • An Garda Síochána is the official name of the Irish police. Often referred colloquially as ‘the guards’.

    Had Ireland achieved approximately 20 deaths per million population over this period, expected annual totals would have ranged from roughly 100 to 106.

    Subtract one from the other and the divergence is evident.


    Counterfactual Calculation (Benchmark Scenario)

    Swedish-Rate Expected Fatalities

    Assuming:

    • Sweden’s benchmark rate c. 20 deaths per million population
    • Ireland’s annual population c. 5.0–5.3 million

    Expected deaths if Ireland had matched Sweden:

    YearPopulation (approx)Expected
    @ c. 20/million
    20205.0 mc. 100
    20215.1 mc. 102
    20225.2 mc. 104
    20235.3 mc. 106
    20245.3 mc. 106
    20255.3 mc. 106

    (Rounded to nearest whole death based on population changes year to year.)

    Excess-Fatalities Estimation

    YearActual (RSA)Expected
    @ c. 20/million
    Excess
    2020146c. 100c. 46
    2021130c. 102c. 28
    2022155c. 104c. 51
    2023184c. 106c. 78
    2024174c. 106c. 68
    2025185c. 106c. 79
    Total,,c. 350

    The Ireland–Sweden counterfactual uses a Sweden-level fatality rate of approximately 20 deaths per million population, a benchmark of road safety performance among EU countries. This yields an expected annual Irish fatality count of roughly 100–106 for the period 2020–2025. Comparing against actual Irish fatalities reported by An Garda Síochána and the RSA, the cumulative difference is approximately 350 excess fatalities over this six-year span relative to the Sweden benchmark. Using slightly higher Swedish benchmark rates (22–24 per million) changes the estimate but still yields a significant excess range (e.g., roughly 230–290 excess fatalities), and does not alter the substantive conclusion.


    Methodological Appendix:
    Benchmark Counterfactual Estimation

    The “c. 350 excess fatalities” estimate is a comparative benchmark calculation rather than a mechanistic causal model. It compares Ireland’s observed road fatalities (as reported annually by the Road Safety Authority and An Garda Síochána for public roads) with the number expected if Ireland had recorded Sweden’s observed fatality rate per million population over the same period (2020–2025).

    The benchmark rate is set at approximately 20 fatalities per million population, consistent with Sweden’s recent performance as reported in European road-safety summaries. Ireland’s mid-year population during the period ranged from approximately 5.0 to 5.3 million. Expected fatalities were calculated by multiplying the Sweden benchmark rate by Ireland’s annual population and rounding to the nearest whole number. Excess fatalities are defined as observed minus benchmark-expected deaths.

    Because international fatality rates and population estimates are subject to minor revision, results are presented as approximate. Sensitivity testing using higher benchmark rates (e.g., 22–24 per million) yields lower excess-fatality totals but does not materially alter the direction or policy relevance of the comparative gap. This estimate therefore represents a robust comparative outcomes differential, not proof of single-cause attribution.

    Roughly 350 lives.

    No complex econometric model is required to see it.

    Cite this article
    Jordan, Eugene. "350 Excess Road Fatalities Since 2020." Institutional Systems Analysis. 2026. Accessed on November 18, 2026 at 08:27. https://eugenejordan.ie/350-excess-road-fatalities-since-2020/.